|
S&P Research on Fees Show Cheaper Funds Continuing to Outperform Their More Expensive Peers
NEW YORK, June 29 /PRNewswire/ -- In a review of the fees being levied
upon investors by equity mutual funds, Standard & Poor's -- a leading provider
of independent investment research, ratings and indices -- has determined that
funds with lower than average expense ratios are continuing to outperform
their more expensive peers over the long-term. According to Standard & Poor's
database of over 17,000 U.S. mutual funds, funds charging smaller than average
fees to investors outperformed their more expensive counterparts in 8 out of
the 9 investment styles over a one-, three-, five-, and ten-year annualized
basis. The only investment style to buck the trend is mid-cap blend, whose
five- and ten-year annualized returns outpaced their less expensive peers.
"Few, if any, fund characteristics can be linked to performance more so
than the level of expenses," adds Standard & Poor's Managing Director, Phil
Edwards. "As Standard & Poor's research has shown for the second consecutive
year, high levels of expenses can significantly eat away at a fund's overall
performance. It is important for both investors and financial advisors to
keep fund expenses in the forefront of their analysis when assembling a
portfolio."
To reach its conclusions, Standard & Poor's determined the average expense
ratio for each of the nine domestic fund styles, and then sorted the funds
into two categories - those with an expense ratio below the average of their
peers and those with an expense ratio that was higher. The average annualized
return for each of the two categories was compared over a one-, three-, five-,
and ten-year performance period to determine if a fund's return justified the
level of its expenses. Standard & Poor's concluded that for funds with larger
than average expense ratios a higher return was not necessarily something
investors came away with.
"Given the results of this study, it is clear that expenses continue to
play a significant role in the overall return of a mutual fund," continues
Edwards. "Since a fund's expenses are typically stated in percentage terms,
it is often difficult for investors to understand the cost implications.
Standard & Poor's believes that investors would be better served by stating
expenses in dollar and cents terms."
A table showing the average performance of the funds with expense ratios
above and below the average for their investment style can be found at the end
of this release.
Style Category 1-Year 3-Year 5-Year
Return(%) Return(%) Return(%)
Large-Cap Growth Fund
Funds Above Average Expense Ratio 14.75 -6.97 -5.04
Funds Below Average Expense Ratio 16.07 -5.32 -3.37
Large-Cap Blend Fund
Funds Above Average Expense Ratio 14.93 -3.89 -2.50
Funds Below Average Expense Ratio 17.27 -2.51 -1.26
Large-Cap Value Fund
Funds Above Average Expense Ratio 17.74 -1.53 0.84
Funds Below Average Expense Ratio 18.79 0.01 1.81
Mid-Cap Growth Fund
Funds Above Average Expense Ratio 21.03 -4.45 0.69
Funds Below Average Expense Ratio 22.83 -3.14 2.39
Mid-Cap Blend Fund
Funds Above Average Expense Ratio 23.35 3.38 8.37*
Funds Below Average Expense Ratio 25.47 4.93 7.99
Mid-Cap Value Fund
Funds Above Average Expense Ratio 25.94 6.89 8.01
Funds Below Average Expense Ratio 26.18 7.29 9.83
Small-Cap Growth Fund
Funds Above Average Expense Ratio 26.04 -2.58 2.88
Funds Below Average Expense Ratio 27.50 -0.77 5.65
Small-Cap Blend Fund
Funds Above Average Expense Ratio 30.67 5.60 7.83
Funds Below Average Expense Ratio 30.01 7.33 9.79
Small-Cap Value Fund
Funds Above Average Expense Ratio 30.73 9.39 12.20
Funds Below Average Expense Ratio 31.78 11.22 13.33
Style Category 10-Year Average Value
Return(%) Expense of
Ratio $1,000
Invested 10
Years Ago
Large-Cap Growth Fund
Funds Above Average Expense Ratio 7.19 2.14 $2047
Funds Below Average Expense Ratio 8.90 1.09 $2388
Large-Cap Blend Fund
Funds Above Average Expense Ratio 7.93 1.85 $2210
Funds Below Average Expense Ratio 10.01 0.75 $2632
Large-Cap Value Fund
Funds Above Average Expense Ratio 9.19 1.93 $2441
Funds Below Average Expense Ratio 10.53 0.99 $2762
Mid-Cap Growth Fund
Funds Above Average Expense Ratio 6.56 2.39 $2145
Funds Below Average Expense Ratio 9.47 1.23 $2604
Mid-Cap Blend Fund
Funds Above Average Expense Ratio 12.13* 1.84 $3118
Funds Below Average Expense Ratio 12.12 0.80 $2767
Mid-Cap Value Fund
Funds Above Average Expense Ratio 11.01 2.02 $3155
Funds Below Average Expense Ratio 12.21 1.16 $3205
Small-Cap Growth Fund
Funds Above Average Expense Ratio 6.47 2.38 $2,004
Funds Below Average Expense Ratio 10.29 1.36 $2,755
Small-Cap Blend Fund
Funds Above Average Expense Ratio 10.72 2.03 $2830
Funds Below Average Expense Ratio 11.51 0.96 $3044
Small-Cap Value Fund
Funds Above Average Expense Ratio 11.36 2.16 $2983
Funds Below Average Expense Ratio 13.40 1.20 $3568
* Denotes where funds with above average expense ratio outperformed less
expensive peers
Source: Standard & Poor's.
Total returns include reinvested dividends.
Data as of: 5/31/04
About Standard & Poor's
Standard & Poor's is a leading global authority in funds research,
providing comprehensive information on more than 80,000 equity, bond, and
money market funds worldwide. A team of more than 43 professionals in
10 countries who analyze funds carry out three basic types of activities
relating to mutual funds: fund selection, manager monitoring, and reporting
and evaluation. In addition, Standard & Poor's also evaluates more than
16,000 U.S. mutual funds through its STARS ranking system.
Standard & Poor's, a division of The McGraw-Hill Companies (NYSE: MHP), is
the world's foremost provider of independent credit ratings, indices, risk
evaluation, investment research, data and valuations. With 5,000 employees
located in 20 countries, Standard & Poor's is an essential part of the world's
financial infrastructure and has played a leading role for more than 140 years
in providing investors with the independent benchmarks they need to feel more
confident about their investment and financial decisions. For more
information, visit http://www.standardandpoors.com.
SOURCE Standard & Poor'sWeb Site: http://www.standardandpoors.com |